Peruvian Biologist's Defamation Conviction OverturnedJanuary 14, 2011
The case of Peruvian biologist Ernesto Bustamante Donayre, which has attracted attention in the global science community, has ended with the overturning of his conviction.
The conflict started in 2007 when Antonietta Ornella Gutiérrez Rosati published a report about the presence of GM maize in Peru, where there were still no regulations on planting GM crops. In response to Gutiérrez' report, Bustamante submitted an opinion article that stated Gutiérrez' reports to be "absurdly improbable" and based on "gross procedural errors." He also asked Gutiérrez to submit the report for peer review. This led Gutiérrez to file a defamation case against Bustamante, where he was comdemned guilty last April 2010.
The National Institute for Agrarian Innovation (INIA) in Lima tried to replicate Gutiérrez's study but has failed to find GM maize, despite examining 162 samples, more than 3 times the amount of samples in Gutiérrez' study.
Last month, Bustamante's convinction was overturned because the appeal judge found that a lower court had not demonstrated that Bustamante had sufficient motivation to harm or defame his alleged victim.
Read the complete story at http://www.nature.com/news/2011/110111/full/news.2011.10.html.
The Crop Biotech Update is a weekly newsletter of ISAAA, a not-for-profit organization. The CBU is distributed for free to over 23,000 subscribers worldwide to inform them about the key developments in biosciences, especially in agricultural biotechnology. Your support will help us in our mission to feed the world with knowledge. You can help by donating as little as $10.
See more articles:
News from Around the World
- CBU's Subscribers Now Total 1 Million (and Still Growing)
- Experts Take on Global Food Security Debate
- Mali IER Board OKs GM Cotton Research
- Nigeria Gets Improved Cassava Varieties
- Donald Danforth Plant Science Center Receives $70M Grant
- Gene Helps Plants Use Less Water Without Reducing Biomass
- Wildflower Colors Tell Butterflies to Prevent Sterile Offsprings
- Genome Study Identifies Key Maize Genes for Increased Yield
- Study Analyzes Marginal Land for Biofuel Production
- US$40 M Research Grant to UC Davis
- Development of Hardier Varieties of Flax for Canada
- Peruvian Biologist's Defamation Conviction Overturned
- Choudhary Gets COMSTECH 2010 Award
- University of Southern Mindanao Conducts Seminar on Bt Eggplant
- Scientists Discover Genes' Battle Over Sex Determination
- Three Years More for GM Clover Release
- Local Government of Cotabato, Philippines to Exercise Informed Decision on Bt Eggplant
- European Agriculture Polices Need Overhaul in Light of Food Price Shock
- EC-JRC Notification for Field Trial of GM Sugarbeet
- GM Cottonseed Analyzed for Ruminant Feeding
- Overexpression of Ethylene Response Factor Confers Cold Tolerance in Rice Seedlings
- Stacked Genes Enhances Drought Tolerance in Maize
- Borlaug Fellowship Program 2011
- Plant Protection and Plant Health in Europe
- 5th World Congress of Conservation Agriculture
- EFSA Newsletter on Plants
Read the latest:
- Crop Biotech Update (August 3, 2022)
- Genome Editing Supplement (July 20, 2022)
- Gene Drive Supplement (July 27, 2022)
Subscribe to CBU: