Methodological Flaws Found in Studies Reporting Adverse Effects of GM CropsAugust 2, 2017
Scientists Miguel Sanchez of ChileBio and Wayne Parrott of the University of Georgia released an article on their review of research papers that are usually used as evidence of negative effects of GM food and feed. Their review article is published in the Plant Biotechnology Journal.
A total of 35 articles were evaluated. These articles are often cited by biotech critics to emphasize the adverse effects of GM crops. Studies not published in scientific journals as well as those reports evaluating only immunogenicity of pure proteins, instead of whole food or GM crops studies, were not included in the evaluation. Most of the articles assessed (43%) were about the effects of herbicide tolerant soybean event 40-3-2. Insect resistant maize MON810 was covered by 23%, while 9% tackled non-commercial events. Seven studies (20%) did not disclose which particular GM crop was used, making it impossible to replicate the experiments. Eleven out of 35 studies were authored by the Malatesta group at the University of Urbino and University of Verona in Italy.
The evaluation of research articles showed that the studies were conducted in just a few laboratories and published in less popular journals. Methodological flaws were also found in the papers, such as failure to disclose important details in the experiment and actual measurement of results, which invalidate the conclusions of the study.
Read the review article in Plant Biotechnology Journal.
The Crop Biotech Update is a weekly newsletter of ISAAA, a non-for-profit organization. The CBU is distributed for free to over 23,000 subscribers worldwide to inform them about the key developments in biosciences, especially in agricultural biotechnology. Your support will help us in our mission to feed the world with knowledge. You can help by donating as little as $10.
See more articles:
News from Around the World
- Methodological Flaws Found in Studies Reporting Adverse Effects of GM Crops
- Ghana Gov't Supports GE Research to Combat Armyworm
- New Assembly for Bread Wheat Genome has 10x Higher Contiguity
- USDA APHIS Announces Extension of Deregulation to GE Canola
- PABIC and ICCBS Hold ISAAA Report Launch
- CSIRO Decodes Genome of Megapests
- Pangasinan Stakeholders Learn about Bt Brinjal, Affirm Support for Bt Talong
- Study Reports SmartStax Maize Does Not Affect Non-Target Organisms
- RPW8.1 Gene Boosts Pattern-Triggered Immunity against Multiple Pathogens
- Overexpression of Mutated ZmDA1 or ZmDAR1 Gene Improves Maize Yield via Enhanced Starch Synthesis
Plant Breeding Innovations
- Transcriptional Activation via CRISPR-dCas9 Mimics Overexpression Phenotypes in Arabidopsis
Beyond Crop Biotech
- Japanese Scientists Genetically Engineer A True Blue Chrysanthemum
From the BICs
- Pakistan and China to Work Together in Advancing Agriculture
- Challenges in Commercializing Biotech Crops Tackled in Seminar
- European Biotech Week 2017
Subscribe to CBU: