US National Academy of Sciences Report on Economic and Environmental Effects of Renewable Fuels Standard (RFS)October 28, 2011
The United States National Academy of Sciences(US-NAS) recently published a report, entitled, "Renewable Fuel Standard: Potential Economic and Environmental Effects of U.S. Biofuel Policy". The report was made on the request of the United States Congress to assess the economic and environmental benefits/concerns related to achieving the targets of the Renewable Fuels Standard (RFS).
The RFS was enacted by the U.S. Congress in 2005 as part of the Energy Policy Act, and was amended in the 2007 Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA). The purpose of the RFS was to "encourage the production and consumption of biofuels in the United States".
The amended RF Sunder the 2007 EISA is sometimes referred to as "RFS 2". There are four categories for the total renewable fuel requirement under the RFS 2:
- ethanol derived from cornstarch, with a life-cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) threshold of at least 20-percent reduction in emissions compared to petroleum-based gasoline and diesel (target:15 billion gallons by 2022),
- biomass-based diesel that achieves life-cycleGHG threshold of at least 50 percent (target: 1 billion gallons by 2022),
- advanced biofuels that are renewable fuels other than corn-starch-derived ethanol which achievesa life cycle GHG threshold of at least 50 percent (target: 4 billion gallons by 2022); (advanced biofuels can include cellulosic biofuels and biomass-based diesel), and
- cellulosic biofuels derived from any cellulose, hemicellulose, or lignin from renewable biomass that can achieve a life-cycle GHG threshold of at least 60 percent (target: 16 billion gallons by 2022).
Among the key findings mentioned in the report are:
- the RFS2-mandated target consumption of 16 billion gallons of ethanol-equivalent cellulosic biofuels is unlikely to be met in 2022, unless there are major technological innovations or policy changes,
- biofuels would be cost-competitive with petroleum-based fuels, only in an economic environment characterized by high oil prices, technological breakthroughs, and a high implicit or actual carbon price,
- because the effect of biofuels on GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions depends on the production method and land-use/land-cover change factors, the RFS2 may be an ineffective policy for reducing global GHG emissions,
- implementation of RFS2 may create competition among different land uses, raise cropland prices, and increase the cost of food and feed production,in the absence of improvements in both agricultural yields and biomass-to-biofuel conversion efficiencies,
- food-based biofuel is one of many factors that contributed to upward price pressure on agricultural commodities,food, and livestock feed since 2007.
Details on how to access the NAS report can be obtained from the website of the National Academy of Sciences (URL above).
The Crop Biotech Update is a weekly newsletter of ISAAA, a non-for-profit organization. The CBU is distributed for free to over 23,000 subscribers worldwide to inform them about the key developments in biosciences, especially in agricultural biotechnology. Your support will help us in our mission to feed the world with knowledge. You can help by donating as little as $10.
See more articles:
News from Around the World
- Nagoya Protocol Receives 65 Signatures
- Scientists Identify Stem Rust-resistant Wheat Landraces
- Visit to the Experimental Bt Cotton Field in Egypt
- Bill Gates Accepts Hunger Award
- New Agribiotech Company launched in the U.S. and Mexico
- Ethical Perception of Cross-species Gene Transfer
- New Genes for New Environments Project Launched in Australia
- UniMelb Scientists Developed Iron-fortified Rice
- Premanandh: Modern Technology, Political Will, and Sufficient Investments are Important for Food Sustainability
- China Accelerates GM Corn Research
- UNEP Report: Asia-Pacific Region Needs Sustainable Industrial System
- Proposed Criteria for Regulatory Decision-making on GM Crops
- Experts Discover Molecular Mechanisms Involved in Flood Tolerance
- UK Scientists Come Together to Help Feed the 7 Billion
- Identification of Genes Involved in Natural Product Biosynthesis in Pomegranate
- No Adverse Effect of GM Wheat on Soil Fauna Community
- Scientists Identify QTL Involved in Grain Weight of Rice
Beyond Crop Biotech
- Living Mega-cells Found in Mariana Trench
- Parasite's Genome Reveals Clues for Treatment of Ascariasis
- Scientists Sequence Human Liver Fluke Genome
- BioMalaysia 2011
Subscribe to CBU: